Lustich.de
GermanCasino NewsSince 1997
Lustich.de does not operate for profit. Surpluses go into charitable projects, for example building schools and wells in Benin (West Africa). Learn more
All Casino News in English
Regulation

European Court of Justice sidesteps ruling on Malta's controversial Bill 55

19 November 20266 Min.by Lisa Lustich
Editorially reviewed by Lisa LustichLast review:
Europäischer Gerichtshof weicht Entscheidung zum maltesischen Gesetz Bill 55 ausAI-GENERATED

On November 19, 2026, the CJEU declined to rule on the legality of Malta's Bill 55, allowing the protection of MGA-licensed operators from foreign judgments to stand for now.

The legal saga surrounding Malta's protectionist gambling legislation continues to linger in uncertainty. On November 19, 2026, the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) delivered its judgment in the Spielerschutz Sigma case. Contrary to the expectations of many litigants and legal experts in Germany and Austria, the court did not provide a substantive assessment of the law's validity. The judges declared the referral from the Commercial Court in Vienna inadmissible, meaning the law known as Bill 55 remains in force for the time being.

The controversial law, officially titled Article 56A, was introduced by Malta to shield domestic companies holding a Malta Gaming Authority (MGA) license from foreign legal liabilities. Specifically, operators that targeted markets like Germany or Austria for years without local licenses use this shield to block claims for the reimbursement of player losses. The CJEU argued that a ruling on the compatibility of Bill 55 with EU law was not strictly necessary to resolve the specific negligence lawsuit brought by Spielerschutz Sigma.

Numbers and facts

At the heart of the proceedings was Spielerschutz Sigma, a litigation financing company that has funded numerous lawsuits against gambling operators. The firm sued its own legal advisors for damages, claiming they had incorrectly predicted that Bill 55 would not stand in Maltese courts due to its incompatibility with EU law. After Maltese courts successfully used the law to block the enforcement of foreign judgments, Spielerschutz Sigma sought reimbursement of legal fees and compensation.

The CJEU's reasoning largely followed the opinion of Advocate General Nicholas Emiliou from April. While he had noted that Bill 55 was likely incompatible with EU law, he considered the specific request from Vienna to be hypothetical. The court emphasized in a press release that interpreting EU law in this instance did not meet an objective need for resolving the underlying dispute.

"In those circumstances, the Court notes that the lawfulness and proper performance of the reciprocal obligations of the parties to the legal consultation at issue are independent of the question of the compatibility of the relevant Maltese legislation with EU law." - CJEU Press Release on Case C-472/23

Background

Since the implementation of the German Interstate Treaty on Gambling 2021 and similar regulations in Austria, thousands of players have attempted to recover losses from MGA-licensed operators acting without local permission. Many German courts ruled in favor of these players, as offering services without a local license was considered illegal. Malta responded with Bill 55 to protect its vital iGaming sector. This move sparked a diplomatic and legal crisis within the EU, as Malta effectively bypassed the mutual recognition of court judgments.

The European Commission already opened infringement proceedings against Malta in June 2025 regarding this issue. Furthermore, the industry is awaiting another case: TSG Interactive Gaming Europe Ltd v Gerhard Posch. In this instance, a Maltese appeals court referred seven specific questions to the CJEU in October, which are expected to be much harder for the court to avoid than the current malpractice suit.

Why it matters for German players

For players in Germany, this ruling results in a continued stalemate. Those who lost money at casinos without a license from the Gemeinsame Glücksspielbehörde der Länder (GGL) still face the hurdle that Maltese banks and authorities will not enforce German judgments. As long as Bill 55 is applied as valid law in Malta, the path to seizing assets on the Mediterranean island remains blocked. The German Interstate Treaty on Gambling 2021 (GlüStV 2021) clearly states that only providers on the whitelist are legal, yet cross-border enforcement remains a bureaucratic nightmare.

Players are therefore advised to stick strictly to GGL-licensed operators. These sites implement mandatory player protection measures, such as the cross-operator deposit limit of 1,000 euros per month and a 1-euro stake limit per spin on virtual slots. These rules are monitored via the LUGAS system, providing legal certainty that is currently absent with MGA-licensed casinos. When playing with a licensed operator, claims are enforceable as these companies must provide security deposits and maintain a representative within Germany.

What it means for GGL-licensed casinos

For operators with a German GGL license, the lack of a clear ruling is frustrating. They continue to compete with Maltese firms that feel protected by Bill 55 and, in some cases, continue to acquire German customers without adhering to the strict requirements of the GlüStV 2021. The GGL regularly emphasizes its efforts against illegal offerings, but Malta's legal fortress significantly hampers these regulatory actions. A final clarification by the CJEU in one of the upcoming cases is essential for establishing fair competitive conditions in the German market.

Frequently asked questions

What is the Maltese law Bill 55?

Bill 55, also known as Article 56A, protects Malta-based gambling operators from the enforcement of foreign court judgments. It was introduced to block reimbursement claims from players in countries like Germany and Austria.

Why didn't the European Court of Justice rule on the matter?

The CJEU declared the referral from a Vienna court inadmissible because the lawsuit involved a damage claim against lawyers. The judges found that examining Bill 55 was not necessary for this specific case.

Can German players recover their losses from Maltese casinos?

While German courts often rule in favor of players, enforcing these judgments in Malta remains extremely difficult due to Bill 55. As long as the law stands, Maltese authorities refuse to seize funds from operator accounts.

Are there other lawsuits against this law?

Yes, another case (TSG Interactive v Gerhard Posch) is currently before the CJEU after a Maltese court asked specific questions about its legality. Additionally, the EU Commission started infringement proceedings against Malta in June 2025.

How can I identify a legal online casino in Germany?

Legal providers must be listed on the official whitelist of the Gemeinsame Glücksspielbehörde der Länder (GGL). These casinos comply with the Interstate Treaty 2021, including LUGAS connectivity and the 1,000 euro monthly deposit limit.

Share

About the author

Lisa Lustich

Lisa Lustich

Editor-in-chief & casino tester

Lisa Lustich has been testing German-language online casinos since 1997 and runs the Lustich.de newsroom. More than 400 published reviews, certified player-protection advisor (BZgA training, 2019).

All articles by Lisa Lustich →

Sources & further reading

Gambling can be addictive. Please play responsibly. Help and counselling at 0800 1 372 700 (BZgA, free & anonymous).

Related topics

Further Reading