Lustich.de
GermanCasino NewsSince 1997
Lustich.de does not operate for profit. Surpluses go into charitable projects, for example building schools and wells in Benin (West Africa). Learn more
All Casino News in English
Regulation

Pokémon Cards Under Fire: Lord Foster Demands Stricter Gambling Regulations

19 November 20266 Min.by Lisa Lustich
Editorially reviewed by Lisa LustichLast review:
Pokémon-Karten unter Druck: Lord Foster fordert strengere Glücksspiel-GesetzeAI-GENERATED

A British Peer is calling for a re-evaluation of collectible cards as gambling, citing a recent collection sale for 1.56 million pounds.

The debate over collectible cards has reached a new level of political intensity in the United Kingdom. Lord Foster has formally challenged the Gambling Commission's long-standing view that purchasing Pokémon cards does not fall under current gambling legislation. In a letter dated July 21, 2026, the chair of Peers for Gambling Reform (PGR) argued that the established resale market for these cards raises serious questions about whether they qualify as "money's worth" under the Gambling Act 2005. He stated that it is not immediately apparent why the cards should be excluded when many possess a clear financial value and are easily traded for cash through professional card shops and online marketplaces.

The core of the argument lies in the distinction between digital items in video games and physical cards. Foster contrasted Pokémon cards with loot boxes, emphasizing that cards are traded through mainstream, legitimate, and entirely lawful commercial channels. He demanded a detailed explanation of the legal basis for excluding products with an objectively ascertainable financial value from the definition of gambling. The popularity of Pokémon cards has surged in recent years, driven by content creators and games like Pokémon GO, pushing prices to astronomical levels and blurring the lines between a hobby and speculative investment.

Numbers and facts

The financial scale of the market is massive. Just last month, a man in Woking sold his Pokémon collection at auction for a staggering 1.56 million pounds. Lord Foster emphasized in his letter that Pokémon cards are a particularly good case to pursue because there is clear evidence that cash trading takes place. However, the regulator sees things differently. Sarah Gardner, the acting chief executive of the Gambling Commission, replied on August 11, 2026, that the mere possibility of later resale does not automatically make the sale of cards gambling.

"In our view, the fact that Pokémon cards may subsequently be traded or sold on a secondary market does not, of itself, mean that their sale constitutes gambling." - Sarah Gardner, Acting Chief Executive of the Gambling Commission

Gardner added that Parliament did not intend the Act to cover trading cards or football stickers simply because their purchase involves an element of chance. While the Commission must protect children and vulnerable people from gambling-related harm, it must operate within the definitions set by Parliament. Any changes to those powers would be a matter for the government and the legislature.

Background

Lord Foster is no stranger to regulatory reform. He was involved in a 2020 House of Lords report that specifically recommended changing the definition of gambling. Currently, the Gambling Policy Commission (GPC), established at the start of November 2026, is conducting a fundamental review of UK gambling laws. The focus is on whether the Gambling Act 2005 needs to be replaced by entirely new legislation. Simultaneously, the EU is moving forward with the draft Digital Fairness Act, which seeks to regulate variable reward systems, including collectible card packs. The draft warns that such systems share the speculative features of gambling and can lead to unwanted consumer spending.

Why it matters for German players

For German consumers of collectible card games, the situation remains stable but under observation. In Germany, the Interstate Treaty on Gambling 2021 (GlüStV 2021) strictly defines what constitutes permitted gambling. So far, physical trading cards are classified as toys. However, if the legal interpretation changes in Europe or the UK, German authorities like the Gemeinsame Glücksspielbehörde der Länder (GGL) might re-evaluate the issue. Currently, the GGL focuses on online gambling, where strict rules like the 1,000 euro monthly deposit limit via the LUGAS system and the 1 euro per spin limit for virtual slots apply. As long as cards are not classified as gambling, these player protection mechanisms do not apply to booster pack purchases.

What it means for GGL-licensed casinos

For operators with a GGL license, the separation between e-commerce products and gambling services remains essential. Should collection mechanics ever be classified as gambling, sellers of cards would have to implement the same rigorous identity and age verification processes currently required for online casinos on the whitelist. This would shift the entire distribution chain from kiosks and toy stores to licensed gambling platforms. Currently, there is no immediate risk for licensed casinos, as collectible cards represent a separate market segment. Nevertheless, the debate shows that regulators worldwide are becoming more sensitive to gambling-like elements in products accessible to minors.

Frequently asked questions

Are Pokémon cards legally considered gambling?

Currently, they are not officially classified as gambling in either the UK or Germany. However, Lord Foster is calling for a change in this assessment due to their high resale value on secondary markets. The UK Gambling Commission has rejected this so far, stating that Parliament did not intend to include trading cards in the Gambling Act 2005.

How expensive can rare collectible cards become?

Values vary wildly based on rarity and condition. A specific example from the source text is a collection from Woking that sold for 1.56 million pounds at auction in 2026. Such high sums are a primary argument for critics who see a financial incentive similar to gambling.

What is the difference between loot boxes and trading cards?

Lord Foster argues that unlike many digital loot boxes, trading cards can be exchanged for cash through entirely legal and established commercial channels. While digital items are often locked to an account, physical cards have an objectively ascertainable market value, making them more like gambling in the eyes of critics.

What rules apply to gambling products in Germany?

In Germany, licensed offers are subject to the Interstate Treaty on Gambling 2021, which mandates high player protection. This includes a 1,000 euro monthly deposit limit, cross-checking with the OASIS database, and the LUGAS system. Trading cards currently do not fall under these rules as they are legally viewed as entertainment media or toys.

Share

About the author

Lisa Lustich

Lisa Lustich

Editor-in-chief & casino tester

Lisa Lustich has been testing German-language online casinos since 1997 and runs the Lustich.de newsroom. More than 400 published reviews, certified player-protection advisor (BZgA training, 2019).

All articles by Lisa Lustich →

Sources & further reading

Gambling can be addictive. Please play responsibly. Help and counselling at 0800 1 372 700 (BZgA, free & anonymous).

Related topics

Further Reading