Gambling or Exchange? The Battle Over Prediction Markets Escalates in the US
AI-GENERATEDThe Trump administration and U.S. states are clashing over the regulation of prediction markets, which have grown into a multibillion-dollar industry.
The world of online gambling is currently undergoing a fundamental transformation that extends far beyond traditional casino games or sports betting. So-called prediction markets, where users can bet on the outcome of elections, court rulings, or economic events, have evolved into a significant economic force. In the United States, a fierce dispute has broken out between various states and the Trump administration over who has the authority to control and regulate these platforms. The central question is simple: is this a new form of investing or just gambling by another name?
These markets, led by providers such as Kalshi and Polymarket, allow participants to buy shares in an event that pay out a fixed amount if the predicted outcome occurs. While this sounds theoretically like hedging against risks, in practice it is often used as a highly speculative bet. While sports betting is already established and regulated in many parts of the world, prediction markets move in a legal gray area between financial market supervision and gambling authorities. The intensity of the conflict illustrates how much money is now at stake and that traditional definitions of betting are reaching their limits.
Numbers and facts
The dimensions are impressive. Prediction markets have developed into a multibillion-dollar industry, with platforms like Polymarket generating enormous turnover, particularly in the context of political events. Bloomberg Law estimates the growth at a volume that has now exceeded the billion-dollar mark. In the USA, around 30 states are currently struggling with other regulatory challenges, such as refunds under the Affordable Care Act, which shows how overburdened regional judicial authorities currently are. The conflict over jurisdiction is exacerbated by the differing approaches of the Trump administration and individual states.
"A number of states and the Trump administration are tussling over who gets to regulate an increasingly popular new sort of gambling." - Editorial, Texarkana Gazette
A major point of contention is the classification by the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC). While some providers seek licenses as exchanges, opponents argue that betting on the outcome of an election has no economic benefit and should therefore be prohibited as illegal gambling. The Kalshi platform recently achieved partial success in court, which could pave the way for legalized political betting in the USA, but resistance from regulatory authorities remains massive.
Background
The rise of these platforms is closely linked to technological development and the increasing acceptance of crypto assets. Polymarket, for example, uses blockchain technology, which enables global participation and makes it difficult to enforce national bans. This leads to a paradox: while licensed providers in strictly regulated markets like Germany are under close observation, prediction markets often operate globally and without the same hurdles in terms of player protection or identity verification. The Trump administration is pursuing a course that promises deregulation on the one hand, but wants to retain sovereignty over strategically important financial and betting markets on the other.
Critics warn of the dangers to the integrity of democratic processes. If millions can be bet on the outcome of an election, the incentive for manipulation or disinformation increases. Proponents, on the other hand, see the markets as the most precise instruments for predicting events, as participants use their own money and therefore have a high interest in correct analyses. This discrepancy between the benefit as a source of information and the risk as a source of addiction is at the heart of the current debate.
Why it matters for German players
For German players, the situation is clear but complicated. According to the State Treaty on Gambling 2021 (GlüStV 2021), only providers who possess a license from the Gemeinsame Glücksspielbehörde der Länder (GGL) are permitted in Germany. Prediction markets like Polymarket or Kalshi are currently not on the official GGL whitelist. This means that participating in such bets from Germany can be legally problematic. German players are subject to strict protective measures, such as the monthly deposit limit of 1,000 euros via the LUGAS system and the stake limit of 1 euro per spin for virtual slot machines.
Since prediction markets are often disguised as financial products, they try to circumvent these gambling regulations. In Germany, however, such a platform would most likely fall under the supervision of the GGL if the character of a bet is predominant. Players should therefore be careful: winnings from unlicensed providers can be confiscated, and there is no legal protection in the event of payout difficulties. Only providers on the GGL whitelist guarantee fair odds and compliance with German safety standards.
What it means for GGL-licensed casinos
Licensed German online casinos are watching the development with concern. While they have to pay high taxes and fulfill strict requirements for player protection, unregulated prediction markets are potentially siphoning off customers. This new competition often operates with significantly lower hurdles. For GGL casinos, this means they must communicate their strengths in terms of security and legality even more clearly. In the long term, pressure on the GGL could grow to create clear rules for betting on non-sporting events in Germany as well, in order to drain the black market and direct players into the legal channel.
Frequently asked questions
What are prediction markets like Kalshi and Polymarket?
These are platforms where users can buy shares in future events, such as election results or interest rate decisions. If the event occurs, the share is paid out; otherwise, the stake is lost.
Why is the Trump administration fighting with the states?
The conflict centers on who has the authority to regulate these markets, which generate billions in turnover. While some authorities see them as financial markets, others classify them as illegal gambling.
Is betting on political events allowed in Germany?
Currently, political betting is generally not provided for by licensed German bookmakers under the GlüStV 2021. The GGL primarily allows sports betting with a clear connection to sporting events.
What happens if I play at an unlicensed provider?
Players in Germany risk losing their legal protection and facing potential criminal consequences when using unlicensed providers. Furthermore, protective mechanisms like LUGAS do not apply there.
How do I recognize a safe online casino in Germany?
A safe casino must be listed on the official GGL whitelist. Only these providers adhere to strict German rules regarding player protection and addiction prevention.
Share
About the author

Lisa Lustich
Editor-in-chief & casino tester
Lisa Lustich has been testing German-language online casinos since 1997 and runs the Lustich.de newsroom. More than 400 published reviews, certified player-protection advisor (BZgA training, 2019).
All articles by Lisa Lustich →Sources & further reading
Whitelist of permitted online operators
Editorial guidelines Lustich.de
BZgA problem-gambling helpline: 0800 1 372 700
Gambling can be addictive. Please play responsibly. Help and counselling at 0800 1 372 700 (BZgA, free & anonymous).
Related topics
Further Reading
AI-GENERATEDThailand Proposes Strict Gambling Act: Ad Ban and 10-Year Prison Terms
Thailand is moving toward a major gambling reform featuring 10-year jail sentences and website blocks. Licensing fees are set at approximately $147,000 per year.
AI-GENERATEDUK Statistics Regulator Demands Improvements to UKGC Gambling Harms Survey
The Office for Statistics Regulation has criticized the UKGC for failing to fully explain biases in its flagship survey, which shows harm rates up to nine times higher than previous data.
AI-GENERATEDChicago Mayor Proposes Doubling Sports Betting Tax to 20% in 2026
Mayor Brandon Johnson aims to nearly double Chicago's local sports betting tax to 20%, targeting up to $37 million in annual revenue to help close a massive budget deficit.











