Coinbase Supports Clear Distinction Between Prediction Markets and Gambling
AI-GENERATEDCrypto exchange Coinbase backs a CFTC proposal to classify event contracts as financial swaps. A total of 140 comments were submitted to the regulator by November 18.
The debate over the legal classification of prediction markets has reached a new turning point. Crypto exchange Coinbase has officially supported a proposal by the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC). The goal is to explicitly include event contracts in the definition of swaps. This would bring these instruments under the Commodity Exchange Act (CEA) and clearly separate them from traditional casino gaming or sports betting. Coinbase argues that contracts based on elections, sports, or weather are tradable financial instruments used by market participants to hedge real economic risks.
In an official letter, Coinbase emphasized that such a classification would provide much-needed certainty. Currently, conflicting judicial decisions and independent actions by various states have created significant confusion. The crypto giant makes it clear that it still wants to exclude casino-style gambling products from the definition of a swap. Such games were never intended to be regulated as derivatives and should remain under the jurisdiction of states and tribes. This strict separation is a strategic move, as Coinbase attempts to bypass restrictive gambling laws while offering a regulated financial product.
Numbers and facts
The response to the CFTC proposal was present but lower than in previous proceedings. By the end of the comment period on November 18, a total of 140 public comments were submitted. In comparison, an advance notice in April had attracted over 3,500 comments. A key reason for current interest is the growing importance of platforms like Kalshi or Polymarket. Coinbase itself launched a prediction market product in December 2025 through a partnership with Kalshi and shortly thereafter acquired the startup The Clearing Company. According to CEO Brian Armstrong, the product has already been rolled out to 100 percent of customers.
Meanwhile, the legal front is hardening. The CFTC and the Department of Justice (DOJ) filed a lawsuit against Utah last month, followed by lawsuits against Arkansas and Louisiana last week. Michael Selig, Chairman of the CFTC, made it clear at the Capitol Crypto Forum that his agency will defend its jurisdiction against the states.
„If it's a legal and lawful derivative, it should be regulated by the market regulator. It's not something that goes to the state.“ - Michael Selig, Chairman of the CFTC
Background
The conflict centers on the fundamental question of what constitutes gambling versus a financial derivative. Coinbase argues that an event contract exchange serves as a neutral market operator. It does not choose prices or act as a counterparty, distinguishing it fundamentally from a traditional sportsbook. However, there is strong opposition. A coalition of 43 states, Washington D.C., the American Gaming Association (AGA), and numerous tribal organizations oppose the CFTC plans. The National Congress of American Indians (NCAI), representing about 300 tribes, sees tribal sovereignty threatened. Interestingly, three of the four tribes that partnered with Kalshi in October broke ranks with other tribal groups to support federal oversight.
Why it matters for German players
For German users, this U.S. debate is highly relevant as it shows how thin the line between financial products and gambling has become. In Germany, online gambling is governed by the State Treaty on Gambling 2021 (GlüStV 2021). Anyone offering bets on sports or other events in Germany mandatory requires a license from the Joint Gambling Authority of the States (GGL). German players should ensure they only play with providers listed on the GGL whitelist. These providers follow strict rules, such as a 1,000 Euro monthly deposit limit via the LUGAS system and a 1 Euro per spin limit on virtual slots. U.S. prediction markets like Kalshi are currently not licensed gambling providers in Germany. German players using such platforms move into a legal gray area, as these sites do not meet German player protection standards.
What it means for GGL-licensed casinos
Licensed German casinos and betting providers are closely monitoring these developments. If prediction markets are internationally recognized as financial products, it could put pressure on the German regulatory system. Currently, the GGL is very restrictive regarding new betting markets. While the U.S. discusses bets on weather or elections as financial instruments, such formats in Germany remain largely within the strictly regulated entertainment betting sector. GGL-licensed providers must continue to meet all player protection requirements to maintain their licenses. The Coinbase case shows that the industry worldwide is looking for ways to avoid the gambling label to fall under less restrictive financial market rules. For licensed German operators, this means competition from international crypto platforms trying to enter the market via the financial sector could increase.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between a prediction market and gambling?
Coinbase argues that prediction markets act as neutral trading venues where economic risks are hedged through swaps. Unlike gambling, the operator does not act as a counterparty betting against the player.
Why are U.S. states opposing the CFTC rules?
States like Utah and Louisiana fear losing their authority over gambling and potential violations of local laws. They argue that event contracts on politics or sports are effectively bets and should be regulated by state law.
What role does Kalshi play in this process?
Kalshi is a leading operator of prediction markets in the U.S. and works closely with Coinbase. The company has also formed partnerships with tribal organizations to strengthen its market position.
Can I bet on platforms like Polymarket or Kalshi as a German player?
No, these platforms currently do not hold a license from the Joint Gambling Authority of the States (GGL). In Germany, only providers on the official whitelist that comply with GlüStV 2021 are legal.
Share
About the author

Lisa Lustich
Editor-in-chief & casino tester
Lisa Lustich has been testing German-language online casinos since 1997 and runs the Lustich.de newsroom. More than 400 published reviews, certified player-protection advisor (BZgA training, 2019).
All articles by Lisa Lustich →Sources & further reading
Whitelist of permitted online operators
Editorial guidelines Lustich.de
BZgA problem-gambling helpline: 0800 1 372 700
Gambling can be addictive. Please play responsibly. Help and counselling at 0800 1 372 700 (BZgA, free & anonymous).
Related topics
Further Reading
AI-GENERATEDSenegal Tax Crisis: Licensed Betting Operators Protest 128 Percent Burden
A doubling of LONASE fees in Senegal has triggered a massive decline in tax revenue, with officials slashing forecasts by over 180 billion CFA francs.
AI-GENERATEDItaly moves gambling tax burden from slots to online games
Coalition MPs propose delaying the PREU rise for AWP to 2030 and taxing certain online games from January 2027; PREU changes expected to raise €334m.
AI-GENERATEDTunisian Lawmakers Reject Massive 60% Gaming Tax Hike
Parliamentary committees in Tunisia have blocked a proposal to raise the tax on games and competitions to 60 percent, citing concerns over fiscal sustainability.











